“ We contacted Frank about a private birthday party. He was so friendly and accommodating. He gave us the second floor bar which was perfect for our gathering. Warm and intimate without being too small. And there were tables available in case anyone wanted to eat there. Our bartender, Keira, was friendly, fun and efficient. The food was great, came quickly and tasted delicious. I am so happy to have found McGee's and look forward to the next time we're there. The bar was perfect. Thank you all! ”

“ had to pay tribute to himym and stop by mcgee's came with some coworkers to say bye to one leaving the city we ordered drinks and food but i just got food. the wine had a generous pour the onion soup was cheesy and flavorful- good price for the portion would recommend / order it again the spinach artichoke dip was a bit of a small portion but it was decent flavor nothing special i was disappointed that the bar didnt scream himym i didnt see many tributes to it our server was 10000/10 she was cool would probably not come again but as a himym fan ill recommend it ”

“ Came here with a friend for dinner! We weren't super hungry so ended up getting the nachos and the Mac'n cheese as a light dinner but found the portion sizes were huge! Everything was super tasty and far exceeded my expectations! What I thought would be a novelty bar turned out to serve super delicious food. The only downside is that the main dishes I.e. if you got a burger are pretty expensive. Close to $30 for a burger is pretty pricey - the nachos and mac' cheese were both under or around $20 which is not bad for the taste and portion! I'd come back to this spot for a bite! ”

“ I'm a fan of How I Met Your Mother so of course I had to visit this place! The booth and bar feel very similar to McLaren's. There's pictures on the wall from the show which was nice. We got seated at the bar and the bartender was nice and friendly. I got the pineapple incident (3.5/5) which tasted good. You barely taste the alcohol which makes me wonder how much alcohol you get to begin with. My bf got the don't drink tequila (3/5). It tasted strongly of ginger beer (almost too much ginger beer imo). Overall glad I visited this place while I'm in New York! ”

“ McGee's Pub Growing up How I Met Your Mother was one of my favorite shows, so I definitely had to see the inspiration. As someone who owns Barney's famous 'Ducky Tie' I had to get that as my drink. Ducky Tie: Bacardi Limon, Citronge Orange, Fresh Lime & Cranberry Juice (12). It was a very very good drink, and surprisingly, their drinks were not that expensive in comparison to the rest of New York. I had a great time sipping on their speciality drinks and looking around to see pictures of the crew. I will be back next time I visit NYC! ”